Blog powered by TypePad
Member since 02/2010

You can find 1000+ of my kitchen-tested recipes using the Recipes tab, watch nearly 100 of my Kitchen Encounters/WHVL-TV segments using the TV Videos tab, join the discussion about all of my creations using the Facebook tab, or Email your questions and comments directly to me--none go unanswered. Have fun!


~ Lobster Rolls: The Official Summertime Sandwich ~

IMG_9234For a bib-wearing lobster-lover like me, past steaming-hot with drawn butter and lemon, when I am looking to quell a craving for my favorite crustacean, I indulge in a lobster roll -- a sandwich with big chunks of tender, sweet-white-meat and tiny bits of celery or scallions, lightly-coated with creamy mayonnaise and piled into a buttery, toasted 'hot dog' roll.  It's heaven.  On bread.

Cold-water-lobster-300x172Yes, from bisque to thermidore, you will find a lengthy list of recipes paying homage to the preparation of this beloved cold-water creature, but, none result in the comfort and complete satisfaction that comes over me while eating a humble lobster roll on a Summer day with an ice cold beer at hand, at a lobster shack on the New England coast or on my back porch.

There's no absolute right way to make a lobster roll...

IMG_9240... but, if it's overcomplicated or gourmet, it's all wrong. 

Lobstershack-2The Maine ingredient is cold-water lobster meat, the best you can get your hands on -- for full effect, that means cooking a whole live lobster. That said, high-quality flash-frozen tails make life simpler and more user-friendly for many a home cook. At coastal, roadside New England "lobster shacks", also called "lobster pounds" (indoor and outdoor eateries where significant amounts of live lobsters are housed, cooked on-site and sold for consumption), live lobsters are usually boiled in seasoned water, hand-picked to harvest the meat, and, each sandwich contains a generous quarter-pound of chunked sweet claw, tender knuckle and tasty tail.  In New England, they serve the sandwich two ways:  warm lobster meat tossed judiciously with melted butter, or, cold lobster meat tossed in some mayonnaise -- just enough to coat and never enough to drench.

IMG_9154Whether you opt for the butter or the mayonnaise version, in New England, your lobster roll is going to be served on a frankfurter-esque roll that has been baked differently from the standard hot dog roll.  Its crustless, flat sides allow it to be buttered and lightly-toasted on a flattop grill.  Its flat bottom keeps it from tipping over on the plate, and, because it is top loading, all of the filling stays squarely in place.  That said, outside of New England, these rolls can be difficult to locate, but, they're not difficult to make.  

My recipe for ~ New England Top-Split Brioche Hot Dog Rolls ~ can be found in Category 5.

IMG_9166It's all about the lobster, and, when it comes to making lobster roll sandwiches, here in landlocked Central Pennsylvania (not exactly known as "the land of lobster tanks"), I find it easiest to use:

2,  12-ounce, flash-frozen tails, fully-thawed & at room temp

IMG_91681-quart cold water

2  cups white wine

1 lemon & 2 bay leaves

~ Step 1.  Place water and wine in a 3 1/2-quart chef's pan w/straight deep sides.  Cut a lemon in half, squeeze as much juice from it as you can into the water mixture, then add the lemon rinds too.  Add bay leaves.  Bring to a boil over high heat.  Add tails. When water returns to slow boil, reduce heat to a simmer, partially cover the pan, and, cook for exactly 10 minutes.

IMG_9175Tip from Mel:  I like to place one 6" wooden skewer through the length of the meat in each Lobster tail. You do not have to do this, but, it keeps the tails from curling up a lot while cooking.  This definitely makes them easier to cut in the end, and, even though I have no scientific evidence to back this up, I have completely convinced myself that they cook more evenly too.

IMG_9179 IMG_9184 IMG_9187 IMG_9191~Step 2.  Using a pair of tongs, remove the lobster tails from the simmering liquid and place them in a colander.  Using a sharp paring knife, cut into the soft underside and check to be sure they are cooked-through to the center, meaning:  the center should be as opaque as the outside. If they are, rinse them under cold running water to halt the cooking process.  In the strange event they're not, return them to the pan of simmering liquid and cook for another 45-60 seconds.

IMG_9194 IMG_9195 IMG_9198 IMG_9200 IMG_9205~Step 3.  To remove meat from tails, using a pair of kitchen shears, cut through the soft undersides of the tails, along both sides of the tail, then, using your fingertips, remove the soft underside.  Next, place your thumb under the shell and between the meat on the thickest side and lift the shell off.  Lastly, remove the wooden skewer.  Slice the tail meat into 1/2"-thick medallions and slice each medallion into 3-4 chunks. You will have 1-pound of chunked, sweet, white and perfectly-cooked room-temperature lobster meat.

IMG_9209 IMG_9211 IMG_9214 IMG_9216~Step 4.  In a medium bowl, stir together:  10  tablespoons mayonnaise, 1  teaspoon Dijon mustard, 1  teaspoon lemon juice, 4  tablespoons minced celery, 4  tablespoons minced green onion, 1/8  teaspoon sea salt and 1/8 teaspoon coarsely-ground black pepper.  Fold in: 1 pound lobster meat, cooked as directed above.  Serve immediately on toasted top-split rolls.  

Note:  It can be refrigerated, but, I adore it served at room temperature immediately after mixing.

IMG_9226 IMG_9221~ Step 5.  To toast rolls, melt 1 1/2 teaspoons salted IMG_9223butter in an 8" nonstick skillet over low heat. Increase heat to medium and toast until golden brown on the two flat crustless sides only, turning only once, about 1 minute per side.  Serve ASAP.

Remove toasted roll from skillet, wipe skillet clean and repeat with three more rolls.  Note:  Yes, you can toast more than one roll in a larger skillet using more butter accordingly -- it works great when serving 4 people at once.  For Joe and I, I toast each roll as we eat the sandwiches.

Serve w/pickles & potato chips & pick it up & enjoy ASAP!

IMG_9236Lobster Rolls:  The Official Summertime Sandwich:  Recipe yields 4 lobster roll sandwiches.

Special Equipment List:  2, 6" wooden skewers; 3 1/2-quart chef's pan w/straight deep sides & lid; tongs; colander; kitchen shears; cutting board; chef's knife

IMG_8848Cook's Note:  "Hold the mayo." When I'm in the mood for a warm lobster roll with the meat tossed in butter, I cook the tails differently. Click into Category 21 to get my recipe for ~ Elegant & Exquisite Butter-Poached Lobster Tails ~.

"We are all in this food world together." ~ Melanie Preschutti

(Recipe, Commentary and Photos courtesy of Melanie's Kitchen/Copyright 2016)


Thank-you SO MUCH for your comment, and: you made my day!!!

Thank you so much for sharing this! I was searching for a top-split New England style hotdog bun recipe, since they are not available in my part of the country. What a delight to find not only that, but also this excellent and detailed lobster roll recipe that just happens to be suitable for preparation in a land-locked state. Lobster rolls are all about simplicity and good technique–thank you for the clear instructions and step-by-step photographs!

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment